Failure modes of scrum (and its derivatives).

Scrum goes poorly when top-down management techniques are applied. The following symptoms can signal that leaders don’t know how to trust a team, which might be repaired by redoubled efforts toward delivering high visibility, high quality increments:rJ2

  • Standup is extractive rather than collaboration planning for the day
  • Planning is a series of demands rather than a goal and then self-organization
  • Sprint review is mostly lamentation of failed expectations, same with retrospectives

Managing stakeholder expectations is a big part of this failure mode.


  1. Ron Jeffries, “Dark Scrum,” September 8, 2016, https://ronjeffries.com/articles/016-09ff/defense/. (See notes.)